Subscribe
Previous Post
In the wake of the concession by the government in the case of a 9 year old girl whose underlying, rare mitochondrial disorder was “aggravated” by vaccines, CBS News has reposted an article that was originally published last June, Autism: Why The Debate Rages by investigative correspondent Sharyl Attkisson.
Attkisson offers seven reasons as to why—-as scientific evidence refuting a vaccine-autism link continues to increase—”anyone [is] even still debating the possibility of a link between vaccines and autism.” In particular, she notes that, while government officials and agencies (such as the CDC), mainstream scientists, and non-profits who dispel any vaccine/autism link, may not have direct ties with pharmaceutical companies who manufacture vaccines, there is more “overlap” among them so that “they provide at least has the appearance of a conflict of interest.” For instance, Attkisson points out that “University and government researchers and advisors often do research for vaccine companies, help develop vaccines (even profit from them), and/or are paid to consult for them,” but often do not point out their ties to the pharmaceutical industry when making public statements refuting a vaccine-autism link.
Due to the internet and other resources that are available to the public, “parents,” Attkisson notes, are able to “to find research on vaccines and read it for themselves. They compare the government’s all-or-nothing approach to the research and become skeptical that the government is presenting the whole picture on vaccine safety generally.” Yes, definitely: There’s no doubt that parent-founded and led groups like Safe Minds and Generation Rescue have been more than active in making sure that the vaccine-autism issue is not forgotten, by the government, by politicians, or by the general public and the media. Parents who are directors of these groups, such as Sallie Bernard of Safe Minds, are often quoted in articles on this topic, without their very strong viewpoints on this issue being made clear (see, for instance, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution article about Hannah Poling).
I would like to note one refinement to the “parents” that Attkisson refers to. Like many journalists reporting about the vaccine-autism link, the word “parents” in her article is used to refer to parents generally, as if to suggest that many or all parents of autistic children support such hypotheses about what causes autism. While many parents do at least voice concern (despite scientific evidence to the contrary) that there might be something in a vaccine or a vaccine itself that might be linked to autism, there are also many parents (like me) who know that their child is autistic not because of a vaccine, or something in a vaccine. There’s a broad, big spectrum of parents of autistic children and adults with more than a few beliefs about what causes autism—-and who (unlike a certain mother) know that Google (which David Kirby exhorts people to check to find out how many times terms like “autism and mitochondria” and “mercury and mitochondria” occur) is just the merest starting place for research.
Go here for an analysis of the issue in today’s New York Times.
Yes, NO MATTER WHAT EVEN THE SCIENTISTS SAY, I KNOW THAT VACCINES CAUSED MY SON’S AUTISM and IS WHAT CAUSED MY 2 SISTERS TO DIE FROM SIDS. IT IS OBVIOUS NOT A COINCIDENCE. If only I had known the ingredients and that it is NOT the law I probaly would’nt be so MAD today!
Vaccine ingredients- Aborted fetal tissue, Aluminum, Mercury, Farmaldahyde, Monkey cells, Chicken embryos, etc. etc. etc. I WISH I WOULD”VE KNOWN!!!!!!!!!
1299 days ago
[...] autism topic that is regularly the subject of heated debate is whether or not vaccines or something in vaccines can be linked to autism. But while more and [...]
1385 days ago
[...] or something in them (such as mercury) “cause” autism, discussion—-or rather debate or diatribe, depending on what website or publication you’re reading—–continues [...]
1408 days ago
[...] and issues. There’s certainly no shortage of ink to be spilled when autism’s under discussion. Tags: asd, asperger, autism, autism blog, computer, disabilities blog, disability, Family, family [...]
1450 days ago
[...] and autism in today’s Telegraph, you’d think there was plenty of reason for the “debate” to be “reignited” thanks to Senator John McCain talking about an “autism [...]
1464 days ago
[...] to as if they stand for the opinion of all parents of autistic children, and they do not. This is a presumption that Attkisson has made made before. As I’ve written, my husband Jim and I do not believe that vaccinations caused our son to be [...]
1496 days ago
[...] this need is what principally fuels the discussion/debate/issue about vaccines and autism. Today in Washington, D.C., the federal government is holding a [...]
1499 days ago
[...] journalist Alison Rose Levy considers the “debate” about vaccines and autism in the wake of celebrity Jenny McCarthy’s recent appearance [...]
1517 days ago
[...] even harder when the issue is an emotionally charged one such as what causes autism—and discussions about a vaccine-autism link can quickly become as passionate and incendiary as any about abortion (and note how the notion of [...]
1527 days ago
[...] with their lawyer, Cliff Shoemaker, close by—the autism community has been discussing and debating just what the government said in its concession and what it did not. A recent post by Kev at Left [...]
Donna, I also had similar issues with my daughter.I read this all over the internet!! This scares me.She had all the genetic work ups every 4 years NOTHING comes up just the insurance rates for the whole state. My daughter would never run she did a skip and drag with one foot. Reflux, horrible sleep ,paterns zoning out loss of speech ear infections you name it. You are not alone. OH very important for all of you.She also had candidia in her esoughegus this kid suffered oh my! This was found out at 6 yrs old by her Gastro Doc. Nystatin helped tremendously. Hope I can shed some light and help. We are all in the same boat paddling in Autism lake.
I do remember reading a while ago about the use of antibiotics and shot times too close to one another.This is something we should all google again.I am a creative thinker and I ponder over things. She had a few antibiotics around the same time as the shots. She also had bowel issues start at the same time.I always thougt this might be an answer for some of the kids! This also could be why she has trouble with many foods. We are GFCF and adding more vitamins carefully to her diet and skin.She has been much better and even danced for me the last few weeks.Its so fun to see her improve.Kristina and others dont give up on the diet idea it works for alot of kids.I have a great woman in Toms river that has helped me with the diet.She has a Autistic son thats doing so well because of the diet. He is now 18( Keep the faith )some great new products out now. By organic fruits & veggies this helps with the toxic load. They do taste better the kids eat them easier.
@John Gilmore,
“And what makes you think that this “one case” isn’t applicable to many more children?”
The use of the word “rare” as in “rare mitochondrial disorder” suggests that this case is not “applicable to many more children.”
If not vaccines or vaccine related injury, then what? Is there any other empirically based evidence suggesting another causal factor? They found no evidence of genetic mutation or fragile X? Why is the incidence rate increasing so dramatically? Surely, it is not merely a result of better diagnostics. My son did not show signs of perserveration of behavior, lack of eye contact, social skills, etc…until 24 months. At eight months, he was unusually socially interactive and would iniate play with other children at his daycare. He cruised furniture at 6 months and walked at 9 months. He was speaking in 3 to 4 word sentences at 18 months. An “ages and stages” assessment was done at 20 months where he was developmentally right on schedule. His only health issue was several cases of bronchiolitus from 8 months onward. Incidentally, with all of his vaccinations from 6 months on, he would develop a hard lump at the injection site that would last for a month. I was told this was normal. Two months after his innoculation at 15 months, he had a bout of “viral synovitis” where he was unable to stand without pain from synovial swelling in his right hip (same leg as injection)for a week. After his next and final set of shots at 18 months, he developed synovitis yet again after 7 days. Then 3 months later he started playing with his feces. He stopped making eye contact or calling me mommy. I realized he was no longer verbalizing at all. I think there may be a case for vaccine related injury for a subset of children displaying autistic traits. I believe that children should be vaccinated, provided they suffer no ill effects, such as my daughter. I could not bring myself to get his shots at 4 years. My doctor suggested I get a “religious” exemption, until I brought the episodes of synovitis to his attention. Maybe it was the bronchiolitus and his immune system was weak? Maybe the pediatricians were not as diligent about his physical health and more concerned with the mandated dosing schedule that the state requires and daycares must conform to. Maybe, until recently, pediatricians were not as attuned to vaccine related events/injury and have underutilized the VAERS database. I am not a rabid conspiracy buff, but for me the jury is still out as to the role of vaccines. Why not, err on the side of caution, and at least space out the dosing schedule. Julian was and is a beautiful boy, but I would love to talk to him again. I would like family members and other children to treat him as a person and not a freak because he cannot speak to them, walks into pools, and dumps cartons of juice on the floor. And I would like to know what, in the alternative, caused him to develop developmental challenges seemingly overnight?
Oh,the other 2 sets are boy girl also. Thanks again
Hi, Thanks for the thoughts.Since 10 boys for every one girl seem to have Autism as of 2007 this still makes no sense.Being a mom of boy girl twins I know all about the faternal aspect.I think this case is very rare. I have boy girl twin friends around the corner boy has Autism! I know 2 more sets and both have it.I would love to see some study about this. Lucky that it didn’t happen to both. Have only 1 grandparent left and he’s disabled. My husband has myofasial pain syndrome. I may have needed pills to help me through (wow!)
It’s a fraternal twin brother, obviously, or he’d be a girl, so no, it wouldn’t be unusual at all for him not to have autism, even with an assumption that autism is 100% genetic, an assumption that I don’t think anybody is making. His risk of autism is higher (1 in 10, if I remember correctly), but that obviously doesn’t mean the child will have autism. And no, it’s not unusual. Fraternal twins are like other non-twin siblings except that they are born at the same time. They’re conceived via two separate fertilization events, just like any brother and sister.
I’m thinking that you’re confusing this with identical twins, with whom there is an expectation that there would be high condordance rates in regards to autism (i.e., more situations in which both members of the pair would have the same disorder; with 100% inheritance, you’d expect 100% condordance–obviously, that does not apply to autism).
And there are higher rates of both identical twins having autism. I actually know a pair myself who are both autistic. Their sister, three years younger, is not. I have two sons who are on the spectrum and one who is not.
Bottom line: No, there is no expectation whatsoever that a fraternal twin would have the same genetically based disorder as the other twin, even if inheritance were 100%.
I agree with John Gilmore.He is on target for me. Mom of Autistic Girl twin Brother is fine Hmmm. This is unusual isnt it?( Someone explain ) John hope this doesn’t Discredit you :)they dislike my opinions on this site!! Thanks Deb K
1529 days ago
[...] and Shreffler represent only one group of parents, the New York Times incorrectly represents the debate over the vaccine-autism link and also misrepresents the views of all parents of autistic children. [...]